Double vs. Composite Liners: How to Compare Fairly

Comparing liner systems by leakage alone misses diffusion, attenuation and chemistry. A better framework.

Agencies and owners regularly need to know whether one liner system is “equivalent” to another, for example a state double liner versus the federal single composite liner.

Compare more than leakage

  • Advective leakage through defects, using realistic hole frequencies and contact conditions
  • Diffusive mass flux of key constituents through geomembranes and soils
  • Attenuation by sorption in soil components
  • Chemical compatibility of clays and GCLs with the actual leachate
  • Leak detection value: a double liner reveals problems that a single liner hides

Use consistent scenarios

Run the same leachate head, chemistry and defect assumptions through each design, and report mass reaching the base of the system over time, not just a single leakage rate. Sensitivity to contact quality usually dominates.

See contaminant transport and the CCR rule.